New ABC reporting offers gay men over 35 a way to assess masculinity advice without treating fitness, grooming or ambition as the problem.
On October 13, 2026, ABC News published an expert discussion of online masculinity content and its influence on boys and men. Contributors included Movember clinical psychologist Zac Seidler, developmental paediatrician Billy Garvey and Our Watch’s Genevieve Sheppard.
These are associations, not proof that influencer engagement caused poorer mental health. ABC’s reporting does not provide the sample size or detailed methodology needed to assess representativeness. The research concerns young men rather than gay men over 35 and does not establish effects on health span. The practical interpretation below draws on the experts’ distinctions, not findings tested in this readership.
Seidler argued against treating all online advice aimed at men as harmful. As ABC reported, some content encourages physical self-care and responsibility alongside discipline and confidence. His suggested distinction was between messages that build someone up and messages that tear others down.
For an adult reader, those distinctions translate into useful questions:
The point is not to reject ambition or every creator who sells something. It is to ask whether the message offers practical value or mainly presents a paid solution.
In ABC’s October 11 report, University of Melbourne psychologist Scott Griffiths distinguished ordinary appearance care from controlling routines. Going to the gym or caring about how you look is not inherently harmful, he said. His examples of concern included intense anxiety after missing a workout and persistent self-denigration in the mirror.
That distinction matters more than labeling every demanding routine unhealthy. A question for your own week is whether a routine remains flexible or has become a measure of your worth. Keep strength and physique goals separate from a verdict on your character.
ABC also reported Griffiths’s concern about potentially irreversible body changes. Personal decisions about distress or high-stakes changes belong in a conversation with a qualified care professional, not an influencer’s comment section.
Sheppard told ABC that masculinity itself is not the problem. Restrictive ideas that allow only one acceptable way to be a man can leave boys feeling like failures. Garvey’s proposed alternatives included emotional vulnerability and caregiving alongside creative expression and healthy intimacy.
For gay men over 35, the editorial takeaway is not to swap one ideal of masculinity for another. Looking good and wanting a strong body can sit beside relationships and connection. Neither a particular physique nor a particular expression of masculinity needs to become the admission price for a worthwhile adult life.
In daily terms, question a new rule before letting it reshape your schedule or your self-image. Ask what it adds to your life and what it expects you to push aside. If a fitness message leaves no room for intimacy or an interrupted routine, use the experts’ distinctions to reassess its value rather than automatically working harder to fit it.
Keep advice that supports your goals and leaves room for connection, while questioning messages that make your worth conditional on appearance or a rigid version of manhood.
Masculinity advice that turns appearance into a test of worth calls for scrutiny rather than another rigid rulebook, a distinction GayFitLab brings to its research-led reporting. For gay men 35+ navigating confidence and sexual wellbeing, its coverage supplies relevant gay context that generic men's health advice can miss and helps separate credible evidence from medical hype.
Stay connected for research-led guidance on fitness, body composition, skin, grooming, vitality, sexual wellbeing, relationships and healthy aging. Clear ideas for gay men 35+ who want to look good, feel strong and age with confidence.
Build habits and systems that support clear thinking, steady energy and long term capacity throughout a demanding career.
explore the Blog
